Sunrise on the Reaping, Joseph Zada

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping had one of the most interesting rollouts for a movie in some time. First, it was announced that Suzanne Collins was releasing a new book, and that it would be accompanied by a movie a little over a year later. That’s already pretty uncommon.

Then, they announced the casting decisions in semi-frequent social media releases. Almost every character and actor got a dedicated “this person is playing this character” post, and it really dominated social media for a while until the full, massive cast was revealed.

That proved to be a smart tactic, but so was the casting itself. And now that the film has been released, it’s clear that casting directors Debra Zane and Dylan Jury hit multiple home runs.

In The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping, the Casting Shines

Sunrise on the Reaping, Joesph Zada
Photo Credit: Lionsgate

Most of the cast of The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is operating at a really high level. Some, like Maya Hawke’s Wiress or Ben Wang’s Wyatt Callow, don’t get a whole lot to do, but for the most part, everyone is delivering solid work at worst.

Joseph Zada is the Sunrise on the Reaping lead, and he’s got the most screen time. He spends long portions of the movie alone, which can be a lot for an actor to handle, let alone a relatively unproven one. But Zada shines. His accent slips sometimes while trying the unenviable task of not only putting on an American accent, but a specific Woody Harrelson accent.

His actual acting is very solid, but what really hammers it home is the framing of Haymitch Abernathy as a character by director Francis Lawrence. He loves to use the upward-looking shot; it was a frequent camera angle in The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes.

Not only did the casting directors find someone who could both carry a film and emulate Woody Harrelson, but they also found someone with the right frame to be Sunrise on the Reaping‘s star. Joseph Zada is over six feet tall, and the movie does not shy away from that. He is framed from the bottom up to make him appear tall, taller than everyone else.

It’s great thematic framing, because it works so well in conjunction with how Ralph Fiennes’ President Snow is framed. They are both looked at in the same way. For Snow, it’s because he is looming over everything and because he is above you, me, and all the characters. He looks down on everyone. For Haymitch, it’s because he’s doing his best to rise above the oppression.

Fiennes does good work bridging the gap between Tom Blyth’s President Snow and Donald Sutherland’s. He’s slightly vulnerable at times, showing a connection to the younger version, while also being outrageously menacing and cruel, connecting to the version we know from the original four films.

The juxtaposition of the two characters works so well because they’re framed in similar ways. They’re both viewed as larger than life; Snow is literally larger than life by this point, and Haymitch is the first person to attempt to overthrow the games and starts the fire that slowly builds to Catching Fire and Mockingjay.

McKenna Grace is great. Elle Fanning is a delight. Glenn Close is deliciously cruel while also being completely unrecognizable. But truthfully, none of them, including Zada and Fiennes, hold a candle to Jesse Plemons. That seemed like the most intuitive and the best casting choice made when it was announced, and that holds true.

Plemons picks up the torch from Philip Seymour Hoffman, portraying the enigmatic, pragmatic, and important Plutarch Heavensbee. Suzanne Collins wrote Plutarch in this book to provide a baseline for the character who would really drive the overthrow of the Capitol, and in doing so, she made this version much more overtly good. There were times you weren’t sure if Hoffman’s version was really that good, but here, Plemons’ version has a lot more to showcase.

And Plemons excels in that regard. He’s still a little weaselly as he manipulates President Snow and the rest of the Capitol, but it’s clear where his motivations lie. And he steals every scene he is in. It doesn’t matter who he’s acting alongside; it’s the Plemons show.

He closes the main portion of the movie (before that epilogue) with a stirring speech to Haymitch, and it’s arguably the best scene in the entire movie. The themes were very overt and stressed repeatedly, but Plemons does an excellent job wrapping everything up and ending the bleakest movie you might’ve ever seen on a positive, hopeful note. This may be wishful thinking, but perhaps he can score his second Best Supporting Actor nomination this year.

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping isn’t perfect, but it’s a good example of what can happen when you put talented actors in a movie. That’s far from everything, and sometimes the writing suffers. But good actors can overcome that, and Sunrise on the Reaping is living proof of that.

Score: 4.25/5